CivicShock: Tesla Divestment — Financials and Business Fundamentals
The numbers tell the real story: inside Tesla’s unraveling fundamentals and the risky faith in Elon Musk.
Tesla’s meteoric rise has long been anchored in promises of disruptive innovation and exponential growth. However, behind the headline-grabbing rhetoric lies a troubling financial reality. A deep examination of Tesla’s core business fundamentals — sales, production efficiency, profitability, and market valuation — reveals a company increasingly out of step with both its past performance and current market dynamics.
In this section, we outline the sustained erosion of Tesla’s business underpinnings, chronicling a trajectory from record growth to alarming decline. The evidence points not to isolated setbacks but to systemic issues threatening the company’s stability and undermining investor confidence.
Historical Annual Decline
Tesla's once-unquestioned growth story began to fracture in 2025, when the company reported its first-ever annual sales decline in its history 1234. This moment marked a crucial inflection point, breaking over a decade of consecutive growth and signaling early warning signs to investors and analysts alike.
Competition & Market Share
As Tesla faltered, competitors surged forward. In Germany, BYD sales skyrocketed by 755% year-over-year in April 2025 5, and in Britain, BYD sales jumped 311% during the same period 5. Meanwhile, Volkswagen’s EV sales more than doubled across Europe in Q1 2025 5, and General Motors saw its EV sales rise by 50% in 2024 3. In China, the world's largest EV market, BYD’s all-electric sales rose 41.3% in 2024, overtaking Tesla and consolidating BYD’s global leadership 3.
Sales Decline
European Sales Crash (Spring 2025)
Tesla’s brand collapse across Europe became starkly visible in Spring 2025. In April alone, new registrations plummeted 46% in Germany 5, 62% in Britain 5, over 80% in Sweden 5, and more than 59% in France 5. Even in Norway, while Model Y registrations technically rose, over half were used cars, reflecting eroded demand for new Teslas 5. Tesla’s market share in Norway fell to 11%, down from 18% 5.
The decline continued: Tesla saw a 62% YoY drop in the UK in April 2025 2, a 67% drop in Denmark 2, a 74% decline in the Netherlands 2, and a 33% decline in Portugal 2. France saw a 59% drop, and overall European sales fell 36% YoY in Q1 2025 2. Meanwhile, the broader European EV market actually grew 24% in Q1 2025 2, showing that Tesla's troubles were self-inflicted. By May 2025, Tesla’s EU sales were down 40% YoY 6, and new car registrations across Britain and continental Europe fell 28% YoY 7.
U.S. Market Decline
In the U.S., the EV market remained healthy, with total EV sales up 11.4% YoY in Q1 2025 3. Yet Tesla bucked this trend: its U.S. sales dropped 13.1% YoY in Q1 2025 3 and fell further by 21% YoY in Q2 2025 7, highlighting a major erosion of domestic loyalty.
Q1 2025 Global Collapse
The first quarter of 2025 marked a historic operational collapse. Tesla delivered 336,681 cars, down 13% YoY — the largest quarterly decline in its history 1. The company delivered 50,000 fewer vehicles than in Q1 2024 1, and its European sales fell 49% in the first two months 1, despite a 28% increase in overall European EV sales 1. Globally, Tesla was overtaken by BYD, which sold over 416,000 EVs in Q1 2025, up 39% YoY 1.
Financial performance mirrored the operational disaster: global net income fell 71% YoY 2, with profits reliant on regulatory credits to other automakers 2, 7,8. Revenue dropped 9% and automotive revenue declined 20% 4. The stock price plunged 36% in Q1 alone 9, as Tesla missed delivery targets 9, issued widespread recalls 9, and saw a surge in trade-ins for competitors 9. In parallel, Tesla would have posted a loss if not for $595 million in regulatory credits 8, and final net profit was only $409 million 8. Tesla's Q1 2025 profit was the lowest in years and depended on credits worth nearly half a billion dollars 7.
Production & Capacity Utilization
In Q1 2025, Tesla produced 362,615 vehicles, achieving only ~62% utilization 7. This contrasts with the U.S. auto industry average utilization of 65% 7. Even as demand plunged, Tesla’s production lines kept running, at higher capacity, exposing a dangerous operational mismatch. In Q2 2025, Tesla factories ran at only ~70% capacity 7, with total annual capacity standing at 2.35 million vehicles (~590,000 per quarter) 7..
This underuse isn’t just a technical detail — it represents a massive financial drag. As industry expert Ferdinand Dudenhöffer bluntly put it, "You can’t lay off machines. You have to keep paying them even when you’re not using them" 7. Tesla’s enormous fixed manufacturing footprint has turned into a costly liability, amplifying its vulnerability during a period of collapsing demand and intensifying competitive pressure.
Cybertruck Product Struggles
The Cybertruck embodies Tesla’s product failures. In its first 18 months, it sold only 46,000 units 3. The initial 2024 U.S. run saw just 39,000 vehicles sold 4, falling far short of the 250,000 annual goal 4. Moreover, it endured eight recalls, including critical safety issues with accelerator pedals and wipers 3, 4. The first versions cost $100,000, 2.5 times Musk’s original promise 4, forcing Tesla to release a revised version at $69,990 in April 2025 4.
By mid-2025, the Cybertruck stood as Tesla’s only new model in five years — a symbol of strategic stagnation and execution failure 8. Capacity lines meant to produce up to 225,000 vehicles per year delivered only 13,400 in Q2 2025 7.
Financial Fundamentals & Profitability Risks
Looking ahead to Q2, analysts had projected a ~10% sales decline and ~20% profit drop in Q2 2025 8, underlining the ongoing downward spiral and foreshadowing deeper financial erosion. Those projections proved accurate: Tesla reported delivering 384,000 vehicles from April through June, down from 444,000 a year earlier, reflecting a ~14% decline 5.
This slump exposes the consequences of Tesla’s limited and aging lineup, which has struggled to withstand mounting pressure from both aggressive Chinese challengers like BYD and established Western automakers such as General Motors, Volkswagen, and BMW 5. The result is not just a momentary setback but a structural weakening of Tesla’s competitive and financial position.
Stock Performance, Valuation & Volatility
Tesla’s stock volatility intensified: price closed at $315.35 on July 3, 2025 10, down –21.91% YTD 10, with sharp swings from a high of $428.22 to a low of $221.86 10. It hit a trading volume peak of 219 million shares 10, and a March bearish crossover signaled further trouble 10. Historical volatility remained high at 59.52 10.
Market value peaked at $1.5 trillion in December 2024 4, but collapsed to $900 billion by April 2025 4. By mid-2025, Tesla’s valuation hovered near $1 trillion 8, dropped 19% YTD by June 2025 6, and fell ~20% YTD by July 2025 7, ultimately sitting above $940 billion 7.
Valuation Metrics & P/E Comparison
Tesla’s price-to-earnings ratio stood around 160 3, starkly higher than the auto industry average of ~7 3. Analysts estimated Tesla’s auto business at only $50–$100 per share, or about one-third of its implied value 8.
Conclusion
The data is clear: Tesla’s financial and business fundamentals have deteriorated sharply across every critical metric — from sales and market share to profitability and product execution. Once celebrated as the vanguard of the EV revolution, Tesla now faces intensifying competitive threats, operational misalignment, and an overinflated market valuation detached from reality.
For fiduciaries, investors, and policymakers, these trends signal far more than short-term turbulence; they represent a structural breakdown that poses significant long-term risks. Any serious analysis of Tesla’s trajectory demands a sober reassessment of its viability as a leading force in the automotive and clean energy sectors. Ultimately, it is difficult to avoid the conclusion that Tesla’s high valuation today is driven less by sound business performance and more by continued faith in Elon Musk himself. This is a fragile foundation — one that poses serious consequences for long-term stakeholders.
No ads. No billionaires. Just one person, fighting like hell to call out fascism and build a better future.
If this work matters to you, support it.
Subscribe now—because silence is surrender. And we do not surrender.
CNN: "Tesla Sales Plunge Biggest Decline in History", April 2, 2025.
CNN: "Tesla Sales Plunge Across Europe", May 6, 2025.
Newsweek: "Why Our Pension Fund Is Halting Investments in Tesla", May 12, 2025.
Wall Street Journal (WSJ): "Tesla Board Opened Search for a CEO to Succeed Elon Musk", May 1, 2025.
New York Times: "Tesla Sales Fall in Germany and U.K. to Lowest Point in 2 Years", May 6, 2025.
Wall Street Journal (WSJ): "Longtime Musk Aide and Fixer Omead Afshar Leaves Tesla", June 26, 2025.
New York Times: "Tesla Sales Fall as Elon Musk Focuses on Self Driving Cars", July 2, 2025.
Wall Street Journal (WSJ): "Tesla Is in Disarray: Musk Focused on Robotaxis and Robots", July 2, 2025.
A4RG: "Letter to Tesla Board Chair", April 17, 2025.
Yahoo Finance: TSLA Chart, accessed July 3, 2025.